The Good Reverend Roger has talked quite a bit about this in the past. Appologies to him if I infringe upon his material..
It seems to me that free will is an entirely useless concept. It assumes that freedom is something granted, by deity, creator, or whatever supernatural force you believe in. But if freedom can be granted, it can be taken away. If freedom can be taken from you, are you truly free? Freedom granted is not freedom at all.
Real freedom, if it exists, must come from oneself. It originates in our own action, and specifically, our choice of action. Its not a part of a society, an abstract principle. The American Declaration of Independance speaks of the inalienable liberty, something that can not be taken away, even if one tries. This liberty is inherent in every person, and it exists as choice. Not the ability to choose, but the choices made themselves. Ask yourself, do these choices follow my own path, my own values, or do they follow those of someone else? Its not important if your choices coincide with other peoples, or do not. Freedom is having the choice be your own, considering and deciding for oneself, not letting you be blindly dictated, or not. Self responsibility nicely follows. "I take this road. It is my decision, and mine alone, and thus the concequences of that action I take upon myself."
The possession of that choice is where the freedom lies. You may be taken to jail for an action you are responsible for, yet your freedom is not hindered. In actuallity, you may have excersiced more freedom than the guards who block your exit. This is because freedom is not the opportunities that life presents, but what you choose to do with them.
The same can be said of rights. If they are truely unalienable, they are not granted by someone else, they are part of oneself. A constitution is just a piece of paper with some scribbles. The freedom of speech is truly free not because its an amendment. Besides, many say that the US Constitution is dead from injury to its precepts.
I continue on with these as a part of myself. No deity grants me freedom, no document grants me rights. These are things I take for myself now and will continue to. I choose myself. That is freedom.
Ramblings, yes. I had to say it though.
Friday, March 23, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Swote, you're posting again.
Hi BMW, Just to avoid confusion its DI from QS, I cant use that login here! Last night Hawk gave me an ad for a forum where u guys hang out, I cant get in there now to get it! Hope u got my u2u ok before lock down. Ok I am never gonna totally agree with you guys but I think we made ground and earned mutual respect? My time is limited as I do spend a lot of time on a forum more close to my path but if u can give me the details of that forum I sure wud like to drop by and say hi to you guys now and again!If u wud be so good my email is cn.shailes@virgin.net
Regards DI
Post a Comment